All I could smell was a fireplace which I guess is the point, just didn’t smell good on me. Was more masculine than expected.

Great scent vanilla Smokey smell. Smells like I’ve been sitting by a fireplace. Perfect scent for winter time

Smells like a sweet and classic tobacco pipe in the best way possible a little sweet and very ambery.

Smokey and sweet, almost exotic in a way. Different, attention grabbing, and powerful.

Smells good

Smells good, not bad at all. Great for cold weather.

This is a great musky, androgynous scene. Initial note is strong smoke, but once it settles you get the chestnut and vanilla notes. I love wearing this fragrance October-December.

As a floral girl, I went out of my comfort zone trying this. It’s very smoky. Great for fall/halloween. The dry down is nice however, it does not last long whatsoever.

I do not have words for how bad this smells. It doesn't smell like any fire I've smelled (and I grew up in a fire station, so I would know). There is definitely a smokiness to it, but it was like an ash tray held up against your nose that you can't remove. And it is STRONG - scent wise and longevity wise. I tried washing my hands and arms multiple times with multiple different soaps and it STILL wouldn't come off. I haven't wanted to cut my nose off in a long time, but this fragrance successfully brought that desire back.

Smoky, woody and slightly sweet. A perfect fragrance for Autumn and Winter if you like unisex and slightly more masculine fragrances.

This is definitely a smoky, fall scent. It is very strong. I like it but that initial spray is strong!

Such a unique fragrance, I get so many compliments.

The most interesting but amazing cologne, at first spray it’s very smokey but once it settles in, it is amazing very sweet and musky

Not really my vibe, but not a bad fragrance. Reminds me of a strong incense.

Absolutely Not. This smells horrible. It smells like an ashtray.

I did not like this. I guess I’m not a “Smokey” scent person.

I do truly enjoy this fragrance. It is warm and woodsy, kind of like a fall/winter candle...but the good kind.

Spicy woody vanilla with a touch ( or two) of smoke, Cozy and warm certainly easily worn by women or men. I enjoyed this fragrance very much. Definitely for cooler weather and wandering a pumpkin patch followed by roasting marshmallows over a fire. Blue jeans and flannel, outdoorsy. Wish it lasted a bit longer on my skin and I have to remind myself that it is an EDT. There is a lotion available which I'm thinking may help with longevity for those of us having a bit of trouble with that. Definitely worth trying to see if it works for you.

A sexy fragrance. Woody and musky, definitely reminds me of sitting in a dimly lit room by the fireplace. I personally like Jazz Club more than this one, but still a very fine fragrance!

I love this fragrance. Long lasting, Great fragrance for work and night out.

Smells lovely. I just wish it protected a little more and lasted longer. Very a very warm and inviting scent though.

I really love this, it’s a warm sweet without being a candy like sweet.

Smells exactly like marshmallows roasting on a smoky, open fire. Warm and comforting scent.

Defintely a favourite. Nice, warm and almost cozy feeling. Starts off very spiced and ends with a woody, marshmallow like smell that stands out. Lasts a couple hours but nothing crazy.

I was very impressed, definitely a winter/fall fragrance.

Long lasting and smells great, just like a smoky fire.

I purchased this after receiving the sample. LOVED IT! I read that it smells like Christmas in a bottle and was sold. It did not disappoint! Slightly smoky with holiday spices. I will wear this every holiday season from now on.

Smells like Autumn. Super cozy and inviting...

I like to turn on my gas fireplace and spritz this in the air where it will linger for about 4 hours. (On my wrist it lasts about 10 hours.) It's all the best parts of a nice fireside experience minus my allergic reaction to burning wood. I was recently ill and this was a fragrances that wasn't mangled by my altered sense of smell. It doesn't smell overly masculine on me but I definitely like the way it smells on men. I notice young twenty-something males wearing it. This is a comforting woodsy scent with the right amount of sweetness. At times I think it's a bit too smoky but I'd still give it 5 stars or 8.75 out of 10.

Love this sent. I got it for my husband and he likes it. Smell smokey and woody. So yummy.

this one is one of my faves ive gotten so far!!! there is this waft of like, actual bonfire smoky-ness that is addicting and super subtle but i adore it. gonna buy full size for fall/winter without a doubt.

You will not need another fragrance for the fall/winter season! So flipping good! Ive had it on my calendar for the last 3 months!

Very bold woody fragrance. Sweet at the very beginning and a deep masculine scent quickly sets in. Definitely a winter scent and one spray is pretty powerful so be careful. I love the scent for like a nighttime, cool weather occasion.

Amazing ??

Amazing fall/winter scent. More masculine in my opinion, but has a sweetness that I love.

Smokey goodness

Smoky, but of vanilla, but not too sweet! Delicious.

In love with this scent! My best friend recommended it and I’m officially obsessed and will be purchasing the full size.

Literally smells like clothes after sitting by a bonfire. Not for me. But it definitely smells like its name. And unfortunately for me, good if you enjoy the scent, the smell is strong and does last for a long time.

It’s not one for me however it really does evoke memories of sitting round a fireplace. It’s slightly too woody for me but I can appreciate the thoughts that come with it. I prefer it layered with something sweeter and this give my overall fragrance more depth.

Scent was very masculine but wouldn't recommend unless there is snow on the ground or it's around Christmas time. Reminds me more of a Christmas candle than a perfume.

Sexy, sensual, warm scent. Reminds me a lot of Commodity Milk Gold but in a lighter and a bit sweeter way. This is a beautiful fragrance! In my top 2 for sure. This can be worn for all occasions.

This scent is definitely one of my favorites. Spicy,woody...ugh it's perfect!!!

Toasted marshmallows and campfire smoke. There is an almost bitter note in this that really drives home the campfire smell. The marshmallow note has a lightly toasted quality to it. I could see layering this with other gourmands. This is very feminine leaning, but still rather unisex. Initial projection is very strong, upon dry down it’s a lovely waft. Lasts fairly well on skin and very well on clothes.

It's warm, firey, and spicy. It smells like a cozy night in with a fire. I wish the smell lasted longer.

Very Woodsy. Smells just like you have been sitting around a campfire. Not my favorite, but I can see the appeal.

Strong fall or winter scent that leans masculine. 4 out of 5 staying power. 4.5 out of 5 projection. I love the Replica fragrances in general and this is one of my favorites. Layers really well with a sweeter scent like Red Tobacco. Definitely considering a full size bottle.

Too strong & gives me an instant migraine. It smells more masculine and a little goes a long way. It definitely smells like the name but I can’t wear it due to the headaches.

This is one of my favorite scents. It smells warm and cozy, just like sitting by the fireplace.

I got this one for my partner as I know he likes the scent of burning smoky wood from the times we've camped or used outdoor fire pits. My partner has been using it non-stop for the past few weeks and it has become his go-to fragrance. When he wears it smells comforting to me and it has a cozy and pleasant effect. It blends perfectly with his body chemistry and I love how the citrus notes still linger subtly even after the initial strong spray. All in all, it creates a unique and warm fragrance that I think you'll love too!

I felt it was a little overpowering. The smell is nice but, just felt overly strong

Personally not a huge fan of the smell not saying its bad because it is good just not my taste I got several comments from women saying they loved it and I should wear it more often so if you know women that like campfires give this a try

I love this cologne.

NO! This made my head hurt immediately, and no matter how much I scrubbed my skin the smell STAYS! How do I get it off of me??!

I absolutely love this scent! Warm cozy campfire? Yes, please!

Clove oil is very strong.

It has an immediate opening of smoky and intense. The dry down is an elevated vanilla scent. Unfortunately this perfume has not received any compliments nor has it lasted more than 2 hours on me.

It just wasn't for me. I wanted to like it, but it didn't sit well on my skin.

smells like smoke!

When you first spray it smells like a crackling fire. When it settles it becomes a smoky vanilla. Very interesting perfume.

Love this scent but wish it lasted longer!

Not a fan.

This is an amazing fragrance! It's literally like your sitting by the fire with some sweet warm apple cider.. just a delicious smell!

I love this fragrance. Last about 7 hours on my skin. Sweet, Warm scent. It reminds me of camping, standing beside a bomb fire, roasting marshmallows.

The rating is only low because I am not a fireplace/woodsy sent kind of gworl. It’s too masculine for me and I did not receive any smell good compliments from my husband or anyone for that matter. It’s just not my thing.

This is one of my all time favorites. It smells like camping trips, winter nights and marshmallows. Every time that I wear it I get tons of compliments. Plus it is great for the winter seasons if your looking for something to spice yourself up a little.

I would use this fragrance to troll men as a joke. Why? because it smells like a TJ maxx offbrand "sugar" scent that expired. Its irritating in a hilarious way. Almost comforting . What does it smell like? Imagine the black scented marker in a Crayola Silly Scents scented marker pack which is supposed to smell like some chemical headache inducing version of a toasted marshmallow has come to life. This humanoid marshmallow creature is now beset on a winter village wreaking havoc like a Gremlin after midnight. This is the smell of the PTSD the villagers have after being vexed by the marchmallow monster as they celebrated the solstice that winter of 1824.

Definitely a new favorite of mine.

Smell nice

I have received a ton of compliments..it starts out somewhat masculine, but then it turns into a smoky scent of heaven. Like you were rolling in a boujee campfire.

It really smells like you just left a late night beach fire in the early fall. It only lasts a couple hours on me, but I love how it smells for the short time it lasts on my skin. The trick with spraying it on vaseline on my skin really helps hold the scent

I thought it was everything that I expected it to be! It is nice and I like to wear it after it rains.

Truly an unexpected scent! If you love Christmas you’ll love this cologne. It smells just like Christmas. It reminds me of my grandparents house during December. DISCLAIMER: It is VERY strong.

Not for me at all. Very musky in my opinion.

Smells like perfume my wife told me. I didn't know it was gender neutral.

Not for me

Extreamly strong smell that I love. The smell is unique and vaguely familiar. Only complaint is that I feel like the smell doesn't last as long as I would like.

Literally smells like what your clothes and hair would smell like if you sat at a bonfire. Which doesn't smell bad but it can be very strong

Smells like all the worst of note of a non fire. Nausea inducing and extremely overpowering.

I absolutely love this

It's nice but smells a little too much like a fireplace!

Smells so amazing and masculine. People will say it’s a fall/winter fragrance which it is, but I feel like goes great all year round for a dinner date to add a little spice! It last a very long time! I tested it by going to work with it and I sweat a lot at my job and the scent still lasted throughout the day.

One of my favorite fragrances of all time! Most people will say this is for the fall and winter, but I love it all year long. It of course evokes the smells of a fireplace, but also evokes the smells of a campfire. There is a smoky, woody note for sure, but it is lifted by the orange blossom and sweetened by the vanilla base. The perfect warm and cozy scent.

One of my favorite fragrances. It's nice and warm, perfect for fall and winter. Sadly my husband doesn't care for it but I'll still continue to wear it.

Buying a full size! So many compliments

Obsessed!!!! Don’t need much and last long. It’s a very Smokey fragrance I can definitely see why people describe it like a sexy fireplace. It’s a warm cozy smell perfect for winter.